Imagine this: It’s February 2026, and the New York Mets’ offseason moves are still the talk of the town. But here’s the burning question—how would you grade David Stearns’ performance during the 2025-26 offseason? Was it a home run, or did he strike out?
At Amazin’ Avenue, we’re diving into this very topic as part of our daily discussion series for February. Our goal? To spark engaging conversations and get you, our community, involved in the debate. After all, what’s baseball without a little friendly banter?
David Stearns, the Mets’ general manager, had big shoes to fill and even bigger expectations. The 2025-26 offseason was a pivotal moment for the team, with fans eagerly awaiting moves that could shape the franchise’s future. Did Stearns deliver on the promise of a competitive roster? Did he address the team’s weaknesses effectively? Or did he leave fans scratching their heads?
But here’s where it gets controversial: Some argue that Stearns’ decisions were bold and forward-thinking, while others believe he played it too safe. For instance, did the trade for that star pitcher pay off, or was it a gamble that didn’t pan out? And what about the free agent signings—were they game-changers or just stopgap solutions?
This is the part most people miss: Offseason moves aren’t just about the big names; they’re about the strategy behind them. Did Stearns lay a solid foundation for long-term success, or was he focused on quick wins? Your perspective matters, and we want to hear it.
So, here’s your chance to be the judge. What grade would you give David Stearns for the Mets’ 2025-26 offseason? A stellar A for effort, or a disappointing D for missed opportunities? Let’s keep the conversation going in the comments below. And don’t hold back—we’re here to discuss, debate, and maybe even disagree. After all, that’s what makes baseball—and its fans—so great.
Photo by Jared Blais/MLB Photos via Getty Images
